Nexa Advisory welcomes the opportunity to respond to the Australian Energy Regulator’s (AER) consultation on Essential Energy’s islandable microgrids sandbox trial waiver application.
Nexa Advisory supports the development of islandable microgrids where they can efficiently improve reliability and resilience for regional and remote communities. The potential value of microgrids, however, does not establish that Essential Energy should own or operate generation and storage, provide other services, or be relieved from the safeguards that ordinarily separate regulated distribution services from other activities.
Our submission focuses on the proposed ring-fencing exemptions and their implications for efficient investment, competition and consumer protection, rather than the technical requirements for islanded operation.
Nexa recommends that the AER not grant Essential Energy’s proposed five-year, program-wide waiver in its current form. The application does not adequately demonstrate the need for such extensive exemptions or provide sufficient assurance that the resulting investments and delivery arrangements will be efficient and in consumers’ long-term interests.
If the AER nevertheless decides to proceed, Nexa recommends that it:
- Limit the scope of the waiver. Require project-specific approval, supported by evidence that each exemption is necessary and that less restrictive alternatives would not deliver better outcomes. Additional projects or material changes, including government-supported deployments, should require further AER approval. Essential’s proposed restrictions on activities covered by the trial, including those in section 3.6 of its application, should be incorporated into binding waiver conditions.
- Ensure efficient investment and competitive delivery. Require a comparative assessment of feasible solutions, including the status quo, and genuine market testing of alternative delivery models. Independent providers should have access to the network information needed to develop credible proposals.
- Protect regulated consumers from inefficient expenditure and inappropriate risks. Establish clear limits on expenditure proposed for recovery from regulated consumers, with transparent and independently verified cost-allocation arrangements and clear provisions for allocating risks and sharing commercial revenues. These arrangements should be reassessed where asset use or commercial activities change materially.
- Demonstrate meaningful regulatory learning. Publish an assessment of what Essential’s previous ring-fencing waivers have delivered and how those lessons inform the current decision. Establish clear objectives, performance measures and public reporting requirements for the microgrid trial, including lessons from projects that are rejected, withdrawn or substituted. The AER should publish its own evaluation of trial outcomes, including whether the exemptions remain justified.
- Establish clear exit arrangements and consumer protections. Require project-specific plans identifying how each microgrid would comply with the regulatory framework applying after the waiver expires, including any changes to ownership or operating arrangements, associated costs and their allocation. Explain how consumers will be protected given the absence of an individual opt-out.
Here is the link to our submission: Nexa Advisory submission – AER Essential Energy islandable microgrid waiver
